Looking for an easy Halloween game everyone can enjoy? These 50 Halloween This or That Questions include spooky, funny, silly, sweet, and party-friendly choices for kids, adults, families, classrooms, and Halloween parties.
Halloween is all about making choices: trick or treat, costumes or pajamas, pumpkins or candy, spooky movies or funny ones? A simple round of Halloween This or That Questions can turn those choices into an easy and entertaining game for almost any Halloween gathering.
Whether you're planning a Halloween party, classroom activity, family game night, sleepover, or casual conversation with friends, these questions are a fun way to get everyone talking and laughing.
Table of Content
What Are Halloween This or That Questions?
Halloween This or That Questions are quick-choice questions where players pick one of two Halloween-themed options.
For example:
Pumpkin pie or caramel apples?
Players simply choose their favorite. There are no right or wrong answers, which makes this Halloween game easy for kids and adults alike.
You can answer the questions out loud, write your choices down, use them as party icebreakers, or turn them into a social media poll.
50 Halloween This or That Questions
🎃 Halloween Favorites
- Pumpkin or black cat?
- Candy corn or chocolate candy?
- Pumpkin pie or caramel apples?
- Trick-or-treating or Halloween parties?
- Pumpkin carving or decorating the house?
- Haunted house or corn maze?
- Halloween decorations or Halloween costumes?
- Spooky music or scary movies?
- Halloween cookies or Halloween cupcakes?
- Pumpkin spice or hot chocolate?
👻 Spooky This or That Questions
- Ghost or vampire?
- Witch or werewolf?
- Zombie or mummy?
- Haunted mansion or haunted forest?
- Ghost stories or scary movies?
- Dark cemetery or creepy old house?
- Bats or spiders?
- Full moon or foggy night?
- Skeletons or ghosts?
- Spooky clown or scary doll?
🍬 Halloween Candy Questions
- Chocolate bars or gummy candy?
- Lollipops or candy bracelets?
- Sour candy or sweet candy?
- Mini candy bars or full-size candy bars?
- Chocolate pumpkins or candy corn?
- Candy apples or caramel apples?
- Eat your Halloween candy immediately or save it for later?
- One giant candy bar or a bag of mini candies?
- Trade candy with friends or keep your own candy?
- Have unlimited Halloween candy or unlimited Halloween decorations?
🧙 Halloween Costume Questions
- Witch or vampire costume?
- Funny costume or scary costume?
- DIY costume or store-bought costume?
- Group costume or solo costume?
- Matching costumes or completely different costumes?
- Classic Halloween costume or pop-culture costume?
- Face paint or Halloween mask?
- Costume accessories or full costume makeup?
- Cute costume or creepy costume?
- Wear a costume all day or only at night?
🕷️ Funny & Difficult Halloween Choices
- Be a vampire for one night or a witch for one night?
- Spend Halloween in a haunted house or a graveyard?
- Have a pet black cat or a pet bat?
- Carve one giant pumpkin or ten tiny pumpkins?
- Get scared by a ghost or chased by a zombie?
- Only eat pumpkin-flavored food or only eat Halloween candy for a day?
- Watch a scary movie alone or walk through a haunted house alone?
- Have Halloween every month or Christmas every month?
- Be able to fly like a witch or disappear like a ghost?
- Have the spookiest house on the street or the best Halloween costume in town?
How to Play Halloween This or That
One of the best things about Halloween This or That Questions is that you don't need special equipment.
Simply gather your group and read each question aloud. Everyone chooses one of the two options.
For a more interactive game, try these variations:
🙋 Raise Your Hand
Assign one side of the room to each answer. Players move or raise their hands depending on their choice.
For example:
Pumpkin 🎃 or black cat 🐈?
Everyone choosing pumpkin raises one hand, while everyone choosing black cat raises the other.
📝 Write Down Your Answers
Give everyone a piece of paper and have them write their answers before revealing them.
This works especially well for classrooms, family gatherings, and Halloween parties.
😂 Explain Your Choice
After everyone answers, ask a few players to explain why they chose their option.
This can turn a simple question into a funny conversation.
📱 Turn Them Into Social Media Polls
These questions also work well for Instagram Stories, Facebook posts, or other social media polls.
For example:
Ghost 👻 or Vampire 🧛?
Let your followers vote and see which Halloween favorite wins.
Halloween This or That Questions for Kids
For younger children, choose questions that are easy to understand and avoid overly frightening themes.
Some great options include:
- Pumpkin or black cat?
- Candy corn or chocolate?
- Witch or vampire?
- Pumpkin carving or decorating?
- Halloween cookies or cupcakes?
- Trick-or-treating or Halloween games?
- Funny costume or cute costume?
- Ghost or skeleton?
- Pumpkin pie or caramel apples?
- Halloween party or movie night?
These questions can work as classroom warm-ups, family activities, or simple Halloween party games.
Halloween This or That Questions for Adults
Adults can make the game more challenging by choosing questions involving Halloween traditions, parties, costumes, food, and spooky experiences.
Try questions such as:
- Haunted house or haunted trail?
- Scary movie or Halloween party?
- DIY costume or elaborate costume?
- Halloween cocktails or pumpkin spice drinks?
- Horror movie marathon or Halloween game night?
- Spooky decorations or elegant fall decorations?
- Costume party or cozy Halloween night?
- Haunted hotel or haunted house?
- Classic monster or modern horror character?
- Halloween night out or Halloween night at home?
The best part is that there are no wrong answers.
Halloween This or That Questions for Parties
Planning a Halloween party? Turn these questions into a quick icebreaker before the main activities begin.
You can also create two signs labeled with each choice and let guests move around the room to show their answers.
For larger groups, keep track of the most popular choices and announce the results at the end.
You might discover that your guests strongly prefer vampires over witches, chocolate over candy corn, or cozy Halloween nights over haunted houses.
Make Your Halloween Game Even More Fun
Want to turn Halloween This or That Questions into a bigger activity?
Try combining them with other Halloween games.
🎃 Halloween Bingo
Create bingo cards featuring pumpkins, ghosts, bats, witches, candy, and other Halloween themes.
👻 Halloween Charades
Act out Halloween characters, costumes, movies, or spooky activities while everyone else guesses.
🧙 Halloween Trivia
Add Halloween history and pop-culture questions for players who enjoy testing their knowledge.
🍬 Candy Guessing Game
Fill a jar with Halloween candy and have everyone guess how many pieces are inside.
🕷️ Halloween Scavenger Hunt
Hide Halloween-themed objects around the house or party area and give players clues to find them.
Add Some Halloween Style to Your Game Night
A Halloween game is even more fun when everyone gets into the spooky-season mood.
Graphic Halloween T-shirts are an easy option for family game nights, classroom activities, casual parties, or Halloween gatherings. Choose funny pumpkins, spooky ghosts, black cats, witches, skeletons, or other seasonal designs.
Shop Halloween Shirts
Looking for a festive shirt to wear while playing your favorite Halloween games? Explore the Pasimax Spooky Season Shirts collection for Halloween-inspired graphic tees and seasonal styles.
FAQ About Halloween This or That Questions
What are Halloween This or That Questions?
Halloween This or That Questions are quick-choice questions where players choose between two Halloween-themed options. They are easy to play and suitable for parties, classrooms, families, and social media.
Are these Halloween questions suitable for kids?
Yes. Many of these questions are family-friendly. For younger children, focus on fun topics such as candy, pumpkins, costumes, animals, and Halloween decorations.
How can I use these questions at a Halloween party?
Read each question aloud and have guests raise their hands, move to different sides of the room, or write down their answers. You can also use the questions as icebreakers.
Can adults play Halloween This or That?
Absolutely. Adults can make the game more interesting by choosing questions about costumes, scary movies, haunted houses, Halloween parties, food, and spooky experiences.
Can I use these Halloween questions on social media?
Yes. This or That questions are especially easy to turn into polls, story posts, or interactive Halloween content.
Final Thoughts
These 50 Halloween This or That Questions are an easy way to add conversation, laughter, and friendly competition to your Halloween celebration.
From pumpkins and candy to ghosts, costumes, haunted houses, and scary movies, there are plenty of choices to keep everyone involved.
Use them at a Halloween party, classroom, family gathering, sleepover, or game night—or turn your favorites into social media polls.
So, what's your first choice?
Pumpkin or black cat? 🎃🐈
Happy Halloween!
Pasimax Editorial Team
The Pasimax Editorial Team is dedicated to creating helpful, inspiring, and easy-to-read content for families, teachers, students, and gift shoppers across the United States. From seasonal celebrations and meaningful quotes to personalized gift ideas and custom apparel guides, our team researches trending topics and crafts practical resources designed to help readers celebrate life's special moments. Every article is carefully reviewed to ensure accuracy, relevance, and a great reading experience.
